Knowledge Center: Outdoor Living

What Is the Best Grill for an Outdoor Kitchen?

It depends more on how you live than what you buy

Most homeowners start here: “I just want a really good grill.”

That makes sense. But once you get into designing an outdoor kitchen, the question usually shifts to something more practical:

What grill actually fits how we cook, entertain, and use our space?

There isn’t one “best” grill for everyone. The right choice depends on your lifestyle, how often you cook outside, and how permanent you want your setup to be. In Arizona especially, those details matter more than brand names or features.

BBQ Grills & Pizza Ovens

The Main Types of Grills (and What They’re Actually Like to Use)

When we design outdoor kitchens, we typically walk homeowners through three core options: gas, pellet, and charcoal. Each has a very different feel once it’s installed and in use.

Gas Grills (Built-In or Freestanding)

This is the most common choice for outdoor kitchens.

What they’re like:

  • Turn it on, cook, and you’re done
  • Fast heat-up and consistent temperature
  • Easy to use for weeknight meals or entertaining

Best for:

  • Families who cook outside regularly
  • Homeowners who want convenience and reliability

Outdoor kitchens that are used often, not just occasionally

A built-in gas grill is what most people picture when they think of a finished outdoor kitchen. It integrates cleanly into stone or cabinetry and becomes part of the space.

Pellet Grills

Pellet grills have grown in popularity, especially for people who enjoy cooking as a hobby.

What they’re like:

  • Wood-fired flavor with digital temperature control
  • Great for low-and-slow cooking, smoking, and roasting
  • Takes longer to heat up than gas

Best for:

  • People who enjoy the cooking process
  • Weekend or event-based use
  • Homeowners who want more versatility than a standard grill

Pellet grills can absolutely be incorporated into an outdoor kitchen, but they require more planning around ventilation, power, and storage.

Charcoal Grills

This is the traditional route. Still loved, but less common in built-in outdoor kitchens.

What they’re like:

  • Strong, authentic flavor
  • More hands-on and time-intensive
  • Less predictable temperature control

Best for:

  • Purists who enjoy the process
  • Occasional use rather than daily cooking
  • Secondary grill alongside a gas unit

We rarely see charcoal as the primary built-in grill anymore, but it can be a great addition if you love that flavor.

Key Factors to Think Through Before You Decide

This is where the right choice becomes clear. Not by features, but by how the grill fits your life.

  1. How You Actually Use Your Space

Ask yourself:

  • Are you cooking outside 3–5 nights a week?
  • Or mostly weekends and gatherings?
  • Do you want quick meals or longer, slower cooking?

If you’re cooking often, gas tends to win. If it’s more of a hobby or experience, pellet starts to make more sense.

  1. Budget Range

Without getting into exact pricing, here’s the general breakdown:

  • Gas grills (built-in): Mid to high investment depending on brand and size
  • Pellet grills: Mid-range, plus added costs for integration
  • Charcoal grills: Lower upfront, but less common in full builds

Also remember: the grill is just one part of the outdoor kitchen. Venting, gas lines, electrical, and finish materials all factor into the total investment.

  1. Installation Requirements

This is where a lot of online advice falls short.

Gas grills require:

  • Proper gas line sizing and routing
  • Ventilation within the island
  • Heat protection for surrounding materials

Pellet grills require:

  • Electrical access
  • Weather protection considerations
  • Space for airflow and maintenance

Charcoal grills require:

  • Heat shielding
  • Careful placement due to open flame and embers

This is why planning the grill at the same time as the outdoor kitchen matters. Retrofitting later usually leads to compromises.

  1. Maintenance Expectations

Every grill needs maintenance, but not equally.

  • Gas: Regular cleaning, occasional part replacement
  • Pellet: Ash cleanup, pellet storage, mechanical components
  • Charcoal: Ash removal, more hands-on cleaning

In Northern Arizona, dust and debris add to this. Covered spaces help more than people expect.

  1. Long-Term Value

Think beyond the first year.

  • Will you still enjoy using it five years from now?
  • Will it hold up to the weather?
  • Does it match the level of your home and outdoor space?

A well-chosen built-in grill can become a centerpiece of your home, not just another appliance.

What Works Best in Arizona (And Why)

Outdoor kitchens in places like Prescott, Sedona, and Scottsdale face very different conditions than coastal or mild climates.

Heat and Sun Exposure

Arizona sun is tough on materials.

  • Lower-quality grills fade, warp, or wear faster
  • Stainless steel quality matters more than most people realize
  • Shade structures extend the life of everything

Elevation (Especially in Prescott and Flagstaff)

Higher elevation can slightly affect cooking performance, especially with gas and charcoal.

It’s not a deal breaker, but it’s something we account for when sizing burners and designing airflow.

Dust and Seasonal Use

Dust is a real factor here.

  • Covers are essential
  • Sealed components last longer
  • Built-in designs with proper enclosures help protect your investment

Also, many homeowners use their outdoor kitchens year-round, especially in Prescott where evenings are cooler. That makes convenience and ease of use more important.

What Most Homeowners Don’t Realize

This is something we see all the time on job sites.

People tend to choose a grill based on features, not how they actually cook.

A few common mistakes:

  • Installing a pellet grill as the only grill, then realizing it’s too slow for quick meals
  • Choosing a high-end grill but skipping proper ventilation or layout planning
  • Underestimating how often they’ll use the space, and wishing they had something easier
  • Not planning enough counter space or storage around the grill

The grill is important, but the layout around it matters just as much.

A well-designed outdoor kitchen makes cooking easier, not more complicated.

Which Grill Is Best for You?

Here’s a simple way to think about it:

Gas Grill

Best for:

  • Frequent use
  • Quick meals and entertaining
  • Low-maintenance, reliable cooking

Pellet Grill

Best for:

  • Cooking as a hobby
  • Smoking, roasting, and experimenting
  • Weekend or event-focused use

Charcoal Grill

Best for:

  • Flavor-focused cooking
  • Occasional use
  • Pairing with another grill type

Combination Setups (Often the Best Answer)

In higher-end outdoor kitchens, we often recommend:

  • A gas grill for everyday use
  • Paired with a pellet or specialty grill for weekends

This gives you flexibility without sacrificing convenience.

Still Deciding What Fits Your Space?

Choosing the right grill is less about finding “the best one” and more about building something you’ll actually use and enjoy.

If you’re not sure what makes sense for your space, seeing different setups in person or talking through how you plan to use it can make a big difference.

Bring Comfort Home

We serve homeowners throughout Prescott, Prescott Valley, Chino Valley, Dewey-Humboldt, Sedona, Cottonwood, Camp Verde, and surrounding Northern Arizona communities.